Compared
Three of the bills Providence pays, set against other places: the sewer-overflow tunnels, the dams upstream, and the line against the sea.
Sewer overflow programs
Each system below is building tunnels or green infrastructure to stop sewage overflowing into rivers in storms, and each is paying for it through customers’ bills.
| System | Program cost | Per household | Typical yearly bill | Help for low-income households |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Narragansett Bay Commission (Providence area) | ~$1.72 billion12 | ~$22,400 per residential account3 | $638, sewer only (2026)4 | None |
| New York City DEP | ~$14.9 billion5 | ~$4,5006 | ~$1,224, water and sewer (FY2026 proposed)7 | $159 credit for 96,500 households; $250 per unit in 65,000 apartments7 |
| Philadelphia Water | at least $4.5 billion8 | ~$6,6009 | ~$1,132, water, sewer and stormwater (from Sept 2026)10 | Tiered Assistance Program caps the bill at a share of income11 |
| DC Water | ~$2.7–3.0 billion12 | ~$9,20013 | $1,766 (FY2026)14 | CAP tiers discount water and sewer and cut the impervious-area charge 50–75%14 |
Per household is our arithmetic: program cost over households (Census, 2020–24). For the Bay Commission it is over 76,460 residential accounts, which undercounts renter households in multifamily buildings. The Bay Commission’s bill is sewer only; the others include water.
Dams
High-hazard dams are those whose failure would likely kill people downstream.
| Rhode Island | Connecticut | Massachusetts | New York | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| High-hazard dams with an emergency action plan15 | 52% | 93% | 99% | 99% |
| High-hazard dams with a last-inspection date on file15 | 7 of 95 | 273 of 282 | 339 of 342 | 450 of 451 |
| State repair money for dam owners | None dedicated; $4.4M in the 2018 bond, for state-owned dams only1617 | Bond money for state-owned dams18 | Nearly $146M in grants and loans since 2013; loans open to private owners1920 | — |
| FEMA high-hazard dam rehabilitation grant, Fall 202421 | Not listed | $3.04M | $6.98M | — |
National Inventory of Dams figures are what each state has filed; Rhode Island’s federal record is partly out of date, and the state’s own 2024 report counts 87 of 173 required emergency plans approved. FEMA lists only allocations to states that applied.
When a dam fails: Michigan, 2020
After the Edenville and Sanford dams failed in May 2020, restoring the four lakes was put at $398.9 million. After state and other offsets, $217.7 million is being assessed on property owners around the lakes2223. Downstream residents’ suit against the state was dismissed on April 23, 2026; the court found the private owners, not the state, controlled the dam24.
The line against the sea: three coasts
Providence sits behind a federal surge barrier. Miami Beach built pumps and raised its roads. The Outer Banks buys sand and bridges over the inlets. Three ways a coast gets paid for, set side by side.
| Fox Point, Providence | Miami Beach | The Outer Banks (Dare County, N.C.) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| The defense | A surge barrier across the Providence River with five pumps (7,000 cubic feet a second), built 1960–66; river gates and street and sewer gates2526 | Pump stations (48 built, 83 planned), raised roads, seawalls and one-way valves, since 201427 | Sand: about $306 million placed on town beaches 2011–2026; NC 12 kept open; two bridges over the inlets282930 |
| Who built it | The Army Corps, 70 percent federal, 30 percent non-federal25 | The city, from its own capital program27 | The towns and the county (sand); NCDOT (the road and bridges). The Corps’ 2001 project was never built28 |
| Who runs it | The Corps since February 2010: the barrier, river gates and pumps. The city: its street and sewer gates31 | The city27 | The towns and county contract the dredges; NCDOT the road28 |
| Capital cost | $16 million in 196625, about $160 million in today’s dollars [MODEL] | $103 million of stormwater projects completed since 2011 (the city’s figure); $3.7–4.74 billion to finish the 2024 master plan27 | Sand about $306 million (2011–26; the 2026 round not final); bridges about $407 million; the Pea Island corridor more than $72 million since 201028293032 |
| Yearly cost | Corps operation and maintenance, FY2026: $6,348,000 ($3,808,800 to the project, $2,539,200 to the district)33. The city’s own line for its gates isn’t published | A stormwater fee of $30.14 a month per 791 square feet of roof and pavement (FY2023), about $362 a year; $241.1 million of stormwater bonds outstanding (Sept. 2023)3435 | Two of the county’s six occupancy-tax points, $16.3 million in FY2024, to the Beach Nourishment Fund; FEMA reimbursement after storms36 |
| Who pays | Congress, through the Corps; the city for its gates. The households behind the barrier pay nothing direct | Every property, in proportion to its impervious area, citywide; passed through to renters | Visitors (the occupancy tax); owners through service districts and property tax, about half of each project; FEMA after each storm; NCDOT for the road |
| Protected households | 1,782 occupied households inside the line; 18,582 jobs; $2.81 billion of assessed value, more than half of it exempt37 | 41,600 households38 | 16,836 households; 36,495 housing units, most of them second homes and rentals39 |
| Per protected household [MODEL] | Capital about $90,000 (the local 30 percent share about $27,000); yearly $3,560, or $2,140 for the project alone; per job, $340 | Capital $2,500 (the city’s $103 million) to $89,000–114,000 (the master plan); yearly, the fee on the property’s roof and pavement | Sand $18,000 per household, $8,400 per housing unit; bridges $24,000 and $11,000; yearly $968 per household from visitors |
| Outside the line | 75 coastal-zone parcels on 301 acres of lower ground, the Fields Point treatment plant among them. 589 flood policies citywide; behind the barrier, 329 in zone X at a median $4,120, one on a primary residence37 | The mainland waits on the Corps’ Back Bay plan: walls dropped, $2.66 billion of house-lifting and floodproofing, authorized in December 2024, unfunded40. Flood premiums run eightfold from inland Hialeah ($357–402) to the beach ($2,480–3,080)41 | Rodanthe and north Buxton, between sand cycles: 32 houses have fallen into the sea since 2020, 20 of them since September 202542. The county now buys one at a time ($250,000)43. Flood premiums there run $493–669 against $11,513 of claims paid per policy41 |
Per household is our arithmetic, and the denominator is a choice. Providence: occupied households in the 2020 Census blocks inside the barrier’s levee-credited area, from Inside the Line; the barrier protects more jobs and tax base than homes. Miami Beach: households, 2020–24. Dare County: households and housing units; the sand protects the units, 54 percent of which are nobody’s household. The 1966 cost is scaled to today by the consumer price index, about tenfold. Press figures of $400–600 million for Miami Beach’s program are not reconciled with the city’s $103 million and are left out.
An island buys cash, not protection. Jamaica’s parametric insurance and catastrophe bond paid about $242 million within weeks of Hurricane Melissa (2025)4445, against damage the World Bank and IDB put at $8.8 billion46: about three cents on the dollar. Puerto Rico after Maria was obligated $35.6 billion in FEMA public assistance, about $22,700 per housing unit [MODEL]47; its power authority had spent $2.7 billion of $11.1 billion by December 202548.
Up the coast
The same question, from Maine to Georgia: what holds the water back, who pays for it, and who is left outside the line.
| Place | The defense | Cost | Who pays | Per unit [MODEL] | Outside the line |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Portland, Maine | None built. Repair money after the record tide of Jan. 13, 2024 | A $60 million state package: $21.2 million to 68 working waterfronts49, $25.2 million to 39 towns, Portland $3.6 million50; FEMA public assistance $51.0 million statewide51 | Maine's General Fund; FEMA for public works | Four Portland wharf owners got $6.7 million, about $1.7 million each52 | Private wharves FEMA can't reach |
| Hampton, N.H. | Town seawalls and drainage; state seawalls on Route 1A | Route 1A: $20.3 million federal53; Hampton: $2.7 million seawall, $4.1 million drainage54 | The town; the federal highway program. FEMA public assistance to Hampton $380,56555 | — | Homeowners: the state requested no FEMA household aid56; 6 of about 40 eligible homes applied to be raised54 |
| New York Harbor | Harbor barriers studied and parked; the East Side wall in Manhattan; dunes in the Rockaways; buyouts on Staten Island | Harbor plan $52.6 billion, parked57; East Side $1.45 billion58; Rockaways $961.8 million59; Staten Island buyouts about $200–230 million60 | The East Side: the city about 77 percent, HUD $338 million61; the Rockaways' first build, federal59 | East Side about $13,200 per resident protected (110,000); Staten Island about $370,000–460,000 per home bought (500–540) | Staten Island blocks that asked into the buyouts were refused in 201462 |
| The Jersey Shore | Corps beach fill and dunes; voluntary buyouts inland (Blue Acres) | Long Beach Island $128 million, federal63; Blue Acres more than $234 million paid for more than 1,200 homes64 | Nourishment: 65 percent federal, 26.25 state, 8.75 the town; the state's share from the realty transfer fee65 | About $1,909 per foot of beach (Long Beach Island); about $195,000 per property bought | No buyouts on the oceanfront: no willing sellers66. The Wildwoods project ended in Nov. 2025 after two towns withdrew67 |
| Annapolis and Baltimore | Annapolis: a barrier and pump station at City Dock. Baltimore: a stormwater fee | City Dock about $90 million68, at least $47.8 million federal69; Baltimore fee revenue $55.73 million (FY2024)70 | Annapolis: federal grants, and a garage handed to a private operator for $25 million up front71. Baltimore: by impervious area; worship and school buildings $12 per unit72 | Baltimore about $254 a year per paying property (219,335)70 | City Dock businesses carried the flood and construction losses68 |
| Norfolk, Va. | About eight miles of downtown floodwall, a surge barrier, pump stations | $6.134 billion, up from $1.4 billion; done 203773 | 65 percent federal; the city more than $2 billion73; the state about $86.5 million so far74 | — | Five Southside neighborhoods get no wall; their elevation program is paused75 |
| Charleston, S.C. | A peninsula wall, redesigned as a 10-foot raised Battery | About $1.3 billion (the city's figure)76; $1.132 billion in the 2022 Chief's Report77 | 65 percent federal; the city about $455 million, $225 million of it on the November 2026 county sales-tax ballot78; upkeep, about $3 million a year, all the city's77 | About $38,000 per peninsula resident (about 34,000)79 | About 100 houses in Rosemont and Bridgeview Village, offered raising or floodproofing instead80; three-quarters of the city lives off the peninsula79 |
| Tybee Island, Ga. | Corps beach fill since about 1974, every seven to ten years | 2026 round $20 million: $12 million federal, $8 million local and state81 | About 60 percent federal, 40 the city, county and state82; the city's share from a room-tax reserve83 | — | Cut from the Corps' 2026 work plan in April84, restored in September81 |
Per unit is our arithmetic, and the unit changes by row because the records count different things: residents protected (Manhattan’s East Side; Charleston’s peninsula, about a quarter of the city’s 136,000 people), homes bought (Staten Island, New Jersey), feet of beach, properties billed. A dash means no count is in hand yet. The 1960s barriers at New Bedford and Stamford stay off this page with Providence’s own barrier row.
Sources
- NBC, evaluating the CSO program (2024)
- NBC, CSO abatement history and future (2024)
- NBC annual financial report FY2017 (residential accounts)
- PUC Docket 25-32-WW compliance filing (2026 rates)
- NYC DEP, Flushing Bay LTCP meeting, Dec 2025
- Census QuickFacts, New York City households
- NYC DEP, FY2026 proposed rate
- Circle of Blue (2024), Green City, Clean Waters cost
- Census QuickFacts, Philadelphia households
- Philadelphia Rate Board, July 23 2025
- Philadelphia TAP 2025 annual report
- ASCE (2023), DC Water final CSO tunnel
- Census QuickFacts, DC households
- DC Water 2026 ratepayer town halls
- USACE National Inventory of Dams, national export (pulled 2026)
- 2018 Green Economy bond, Article 5
- ecoRI on RI dam funding
- CT Public, Jan 2 2024, state-owned dam repairs
- Mass. Dam and Seawall program awards, Sept 2025
- 301 CMR 15.04 (who may get grants and loans)
- FEMA High Hazard Potential Dams grant allocations
- Four Lakes Task Force, total capital amount to be assessed
- Michigan Public, May 19 2025
- Michigan AG, Apr 23 2026, Court of Claims dismissal
- US Army Corps of Engineers, Coastal Engineering Research Center, Bulletin FY1967-69 (Fox Point: $16 million, 30 percent non-federal; five pumps, 7,000 cfs; completed 1966)
- US Army Corps of Engineers, New England District: Fox Point Hurricane Barrier
- City of Miami Beach, Stormwater Master Plan presentation to the Commission, Mar. 13, 2024 ($103 million completed since 2011; $3.7-4.74 billion to finish)
- Dare County, beach nourishment completed projects
- Outer Banks Voice, Feb. 4, 2026: Nags Head's $36.4 million 2026 nourishment contract
- NCDOT, Jul. 28, 2022: Rodanthe bridge opens ($155 million)
- Sen. Reed, Feb. 19, 2010: transfer of the Fox Point Hurricane Barrier to the Corps (280 acres; up to $500,000 a year saved by the city)
- Island Free Press: NC 12 closures on Pea Island (more than $72 million since 2010)
- US Army Corps of Engineers, Civil Works FY2026 Work Plan, Operation and Maintenance (Fox Point: $6,348,000)
- City of Miami Beach, continuing disclosures FY2023 (stormwater rate per ERU; stormwater bonds outstanding)
- City of Miami Beach, stormwater utility fee calculation worksheet (one ERU = 791 sq ft of impervious surface)
- Dare County, occupancy tax distributions (Beach Nourishment Fund)
- Inside the Line: who and what is inside the barrier (2020 Census blocks, 2025 tax roll), flood insurance by block group
- Census QuickFacts, Miami Beach city, Fla. (households 2020-24)
- Census QuickFacts, Dare County, N.C. (households 2020-24; housing units 2025)
- US Army Corps of Engineers, Miami-Dade Back Bay Chief's Report, Aug. 26, 2024 ($2.66 billion, nonstructural)
- FEMA OpenFEMA, NFIP policies (in force June 30, 2025) and claims, Miami-Dade and Dare
- National Park Service, Cape Hatteras: threatened oceanfront structures (32 collapses since 2020)
- Island Free Press, May 2026: Dare County buys and demolishes a Buxton house ($250,000)
- CCRIF, system summary, July 2026 ($483.1 million paid since 2007)
- World Bank, Nov. 7, 2025: Hurricane Melissa triggers a 100 percent payout of Jamaica's $150 million catastrophe bond
- World Bank and IDB, Nov. 19, 2025: Hurricane Melissa damage to Jamaica, an all-time high
- FEMA OpenFEMA, Public Assistance funded projects (Puerto Rico, Maria: $35.6 billion federal obligated)
- GAO-26-107772, Dec. 2025: PREPA, $11.1 billion obligated, $2.7 billion disbursed
- Gov. Mills, Jul. 22, 2024: $21.2 million in resilience grants to 68 working waterfronts
- Maine Infrastructure Adaptation Fund awards, Aug. 9, 2024
- FEMA OpenFEMA, Public Assistance funded projects, DR-4764-ME
- Maine, working waterfront resilience grants, July 2024 (award list)
- Sens. Shaheen and Hassan, Rep. Pappas: $20.3 million for Route 1A, North Hampton and Rye
- Town of Hampton memo, Nov. 19, 2024 (via hamptonbeach.org)
- FEMA OpenFEMA, Public Assistance funded projects, DR-4771-NH
- NH Homeland Security and Emergency Management, DR-4771 summary, Apr. 19, 2024 (no Individual Assistance requested)
- ASCE, Nov. 2022: the Corps' $52.6 billion plan for New York–New Jersey harbor barriers
- City of New York, East Side Coastal Resiliency: project background
- House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee: Rockaway project summary
- Lincoln Institute, Staten Island buyouts case study
- HUD notice for ESCR ($338 million CDBG-DR)
- DNAinfo, Apr. 11, 2014: no more neighborhoods in the Sandy buyout program
- Philadelphia Inquirer, Dec. 10, 2014: Long Beach Island replenishment
- Inside Climate News, Dec. 25, 2025: New Jersey's Blue Acres buyouts
- NJDEP, Shore Protection Program cost shares
- WHYY, 2019: Blue Acres' 700th property; no oceanfront sellers
- Philadelphia Inquirer, Nov. 7, 2025: the Wildwoods replenishment plan ends
- The Banner, Aug. 10, 2026: City Dock flooding and businesses
- Rep. Elfreth, Mar. 6, 2026: $35.5 million FEMA for City Dock; $47.8 million federal since 2021
- Maryland Department of the Environment, Baltimore City financial assurance report, FY2024
- Miles & Stockbridge: the Annapolis Hillman Garage financing
- Baltimore City stormwater remediation fee regulations
- Virginia Mercury, Mar. 20, 2026: Norfolk floodwall cost balloons to $6 billion
- WHRO, Jan. 26, 2026: Norfolk gets another $25 million from the state
- WHRO, May 22, 2025: Norfolk floodwall will take more time and money
- Post and Courier, Dec. 6, 2025: Battery Extension planning
- Corps Chief's Report, Charleston Peninsula, June 10, 2022
- Post and Courier, Jun. 27, 2026: the county transportation sales tax on the ballot
- Yale Environment 360, May 5, 2020: Fortress Charleston
- Coastal Conservation League: the peninsula perimeter project
- WTOC, Sept. 16, 2026: $20 million for Tybee Island renourishment
- Grist, Oct. 7, 2026: protecting Georgia's most popular beach
- City of Tybee Island, approved FY2026 budget
- Atlanta Journal-Constitution, Apr. 2026: Tybee loses federal erosion funds