Providence, on the record
Liam Freaney · reporting built on the public record
Inside the Line

Inside the Line

FEMA maps three pieces of Providence, about 418 acres in all, as protected by a levee. The Fox Point Hurricane Barrier closes against storm tides for the largest, about 280 acres. This is that line, and what lies on either side of it.

Across all three pieces, inside the line are 2% of Providence's residents, 16% of its jobs and 8% of its assessed value. 53% of that value is exempt from the property tax, against 35% citywide. Of the 41 storage tanks mapped in the flood zones, 36 stand outside the line, nearly all along Allens Avenue and Terminal Road, and the Fields Point treatment plant is outside it too. The ground there is lower: on the coastal parcels outside the line, 45% lies below the water Hurricane Bob brought in 1991. Inside, 8%.

This week at the gauge

Loading NOAA gauge 8454000…
InsideOutsideMedian ground inside the line: 11.9 ftMedian ground on the coastal parcels outside: 8.3 ft0510152025Daily high tide 2.4 ftGates close 5.2 ftHurricane Bob, 1991 7.5 ftFEMA 1%-a-year flood, outside 12.0 ftHurricane Carol, 1954 14.0 ft1938 hurricane, the record 15.0 ftThe barrier's design storm 19.7 ftTop of the barrier 24.2 ft
Feet above NAVD88. Tan is the median ground: 11.9 ft inside the line, 8.3 ft on the coastal parcels outside it. Blue is the water at the gauge now. Water levels are in italic, as on a chart.
Inside the lineCoastal flood zone, outside the lineRiver flood zone500-year zone◆ Fox Point Hurricane BarrierLayers button: parcels, and ground contours at 5, 10 and 15 ft

Providence parcels by ring

Parcels are Providence tax-parcel footprints whose interior point falls in each zone; condominium units that share a footprint count once. FEMA maps everything outside these four rings as minimal flood hazard, its lowest flood-risk category: land outside the mapped 1%- and 0.2%-a-year floodplains. It does not mean flooding cannot happen there. Heavy rain and drainage failures flood land FEMA calls minimal. The split between the coastal and river rings is this site’s own, drawn from FEMA’s zone and base flood elevation; FEMA maps both as the 1%-a-year flood.

RingParcelsAcres
Inside the line
Area with reduced flood risk due to levee
522293
Coastal flood zone, outside the line
VE, or AE with a coastal base flood elevation of 12 ft and up
75301
River flood zone
Other A and AE: the 1%-a-year flood from the rivers
160245
500-year zone
0.2% annual chance flood hazard
80166

Who and what is in each ring

Inside the line is 2% of Providence's residents, 16% of its jobs, 8% of its assessed value and 9% of its 2025 tax bill.

RingResidentsJobsAssessedTax billed
Inside the line3,83518,582$2,807M$33.0M
Coastal flood zone, outside the line414386$304M$3.9M
River flood zone6321,681$891M$3.5M
500-year zone2771,254$188M$3.4M

Providence only. Residents: 2020 Census, by block. Jobs: 2023, LEHD LODES 8, by block. Assessed value and tax billed: the city's 2025 tax roll, each account placed at its mapped point. Inside the line, $1,495M of the $2,807M assessed is exempt. The largest single account in any ring is Providence Place, in the river flood zone: $731M assessed, carried as exempt on the roll, paying the city instead under its 1996 tax agreement. The largest in the coastal ring are Johnson & Wales's Harborside campus, the Providence Public Building Authority at 1 River Dr., and Narragansett Electric on Terminal Road.

Tanks and power

Storage tanks mapped in OpenStreetMap: 36 stand in the flood zones outside the line, 5 inside it. Each is matched to the tax-roll lot it stands on.

Owner on the rollRingTanks
Triton Terminaling LLC
520 Allens Ave
Coastal, outside7
SPRAGUE C H & SON COMPANY
120 Allens Ave
Coastal, outside4
owner not named on the roll
125 Terminal Rd
Coastal, outside1
Dominion Energy Manchester Street Inc
50 Allens Ave
Coastal, outside1
Triton Terminaling LLC
655 Allens Ave
500-year10
WT Terminal Providence LLC
29 Terminal Road
500-year6
Triton Terminaling LLC
1116 Eddy St
500-year3
Triton Terminaling LLC
477 Allens Ave
500-year2
Sea-3 Providence, LLC
25 Fields Point Dr
500-year1
Narragansett Electric Co
185 Terminal Rd
500-year1
Dominion Energy Manchester Street Inc
4R Allens Ave
Inside4
Dominion Energy Manchester Street Inc
50 Allens Ave
Inside1

Inside the line, OpenStreetMap maps the Manchester Street Generating Station and the Franklin Square, Point Street and South Street substations. Outside it, in the flood zones: Green Providence Wind I, Green Providence Wind II, NBC Field's Point Wind Farm. The Fields Point Treatment Plant is in the 500-year zone outside the line. OpenStreetMap is volunteer-mapped; a tank it lacks is not counted.

Half a mile from the tanks outside the line live 9,493 people, most in Washington Park and Lower South Providence: 55% Hispanic, against 17% inside the line, with income per person of $23,100 against $57,200.

Inside the lineWithin ½ mile of the tanksProvidence
Residents3,8359,493190,934
Hispanic17%55%44%
White, not Hispanic54%18%32%
Black, not Hispanic9%16%12%
Income per person$57,200$23,100$37,100
Below the poverty line20%31%21%
Households renting80%58%59%

The half-mile group is every Providence census block whose center lies within half a mile of one of the 36 tanks outside the line, leaving out blocks inside it. Residents, Hispanic origin and race: 2020 Census, by block. Income, poverty and renting: American Community Survey 2020–2024, by block group, shared out to blocks by 2020 population. Inside the line, 1,034 of the 3,835 residents live in college housing; the poverty rate leaves them out. Neighborhoods are the city's own boundaries.

Where the line is

FEMA maps the barrier's protected area as "area with reduced flood risk due to levee," its label for land behind a levee it credits. The main piece is 279.1 acres; the Army Corps gives "about 280 acres." FEMA credits two more pieces, for 418 acres in all:

PieceAcresResidentsAssessed
Downtown, the Jewelry District, and the Woonasquatucket west toward Olneyville2792,721$2,167M
The east bank, Fox Point to Canal Street68327$374M
The Woonasquatucket, Eagle Square to Citizens Plaza66787$266M

Jobs: 14,878, 1,424, 2,280, in the same order. Acres are FEMA's polygons; the other columns use the same sources as the table above. A handful of slivers under two acres each make up the rest.

The east bank piece sits on the barrier's east side, where the Army Corps lists a 780-foot earthfill dike and a vehicle gate at South Main Street. Source: US Army Corps of Engineers, New England District, Fox Point Hurricane Protection Project.

Water and ground on one scale

Share of the ground lower than each water level, inside the line and on the coastal-zone parcels outside it:

Inside the lineCoastal-zone parcels, outside the line
Daily high tide
2.4
—
—
Gates close
5.2
0%
2%
Hurricane Bob, 1991: highest since the barrier
7.5
8%
45%
FEMA 1%-a-year flood, outside the line
12.0
51%
89%
Hurricane Carol, 1954
14.0
68%
94%
1938 hurricane: the gauge's record
15.0
72%
95%
The barrier's design storm
19.7
94%
99%
Top of the barrier
24.2
98%
99%

Feet above NAVD88. Daily high tide is mean higher high water; the gates close at 7.68 ft above mean lower low water; FEMA's coastal flood elevations outside the line run 12 to 15 ft, and the table uses the low end. Carol (16.5 ft above mean lower low water at the Providence gauge), the design storm (22.18) and the top of the barrier (26.68) are from the Coastal Resources Management Council's Metro Bay plan, January 2009 draft; the Corps' own design drawings are requested. Median ground: 11.9 ft inside the line (418 acres), 8.3 ft on the 266 acres of coastal-zone parcels outside it. Ground from 5-ft contours of the 2011 Northeast LiDAR, interpolated on a 20-ft grid; water levels from NOAA gauge 8454000, converted from mean lower low water (NAVD88 sits 2.47 ft above it at the gauge).

The same storm on a higher sea

Share of the ground lower than Hurricane Bob's peak, raised by the Corps' sea-level curves:

Inside the lineCoastal-zone parcels, outside the line
Bob as it came, 1991
7.5
8%
45%
Bob in 2050, low curve (+0.3 ft)
7.8
12%
47%
Bob in 2050, intermediate (+0.5)
8.0
14%
48%
Bob in 2050, high (+1.3)
8.8
21%
53%
Bob in 2100, intermediate (+1.7)
9.2
24%
55%
Bob in 2100, high (+4.8)
12.3
55%
91%

Rise measured from 2016.5, the same curves as the projections below. Inside the line, these are the levels the barrier is there to hold out; its top is 24.2 ft.

How often the water reaches the trigger

The Corps closes the gates when the tide is forecast to reach 7.68 feet above mean lower low water at Providence, the gauge’s zero: the average height of each day’s lower low tide. That is 5.2 feet on the land-survey scale used above. Every time since 1938 the water at Providence topped it: 35 times.

The gates close far more often than that. The Corps closes on the forecast, before the water arrives, and in practice the water usually stays below the mark. Its own log of operations lists 114 flood-control closures from 2010 through 2024; in those years the water at the Providence gauge topped 7.68 feet on 9 days. During those closures the water outside the barrier peaked at a median 6.98 feet, and reached 7.68 in 12 of them. So the chart below counts high water, not closures. Added October 6, 2026.

Barrier completed, 19661938-09: 17.51 ft1942-03: 8.11 ft1944-09: 10.71 ft1944-11: 7.91 ft1945-11: 7.81 ft1954-08: 16.50 ft1960-09: 9.61 ft1963-11: 9.51 ft1966-12: 7.91 ft1970-02: 8.01 ft1972-02: 7.73 ft1972-11: 8.05 ft1974-12: 8.74 ft1978-01: 9.75 ft1985-09-27: 9.15 ft1986-12-03: 7.97 ft1987-01-23: 9.12 ft1988-10-22: 7.68 ft1990-12-04: 8.10 ft1991-08-19: 9.99 ft1991-10-31: 7.74 ft1996-01-19: 8.32 ft1997-01-10: 8.42 ft2006-10-28: 8.23 ft2007-04-16: 8.91 ft2008-12-12: 8.21 ft2011-08-28: 8.12 ft2012-10-29: 9.19 ft2018-03-03: 7.74 ft2022-01-17: 7.71 ft2022-12-23: 9.10 ft2023-12-18: 9.12 ft2024-01-10: 7.95 ft2024-01-13: 8.30 ft2024-03-10: 7.72 ft1938CarolBobSandy194019501960197019801990200020102020

Bar height is the peak water, 7.68 to 17.5 ft above mean lower low water; grey bars are before the barrier. Complete years at NOAA gauge 8454000, 2020 through 2025: 0, 0, 2, 1, 3, 0 days above the trigger. The Corps reports 3 flood-control closures in 2024 and none in 2025.

Every time since 1938 the water at Providence topped 7.68 ft (35)
DateStormFt, MLLW
1938-09*The 1938 hurricane17.51
1942-03*8.11
1944-09*The Great Atlantic Hurricane10.71
1944-11*7.91
1945-11*7.81
1954-08†Hurricane Carol16.50
1960-09*Hurricane Donna9.61
1963-11*9.51
The barrier is completed, 1966
1966-12*7.91
1970-02*8.01
1972-02*7.73
1972-11*8.05
1974-12*8.74
1978-01*9.75
1985-09-27Hurricane Gloria9.15
1986-12-037.97
1987-01-239.12
1988-10-227.68
1990-12-048.10
1991-08-19Hurricane Bob9.99
1991-10-31The Perfect Storm7.74
1996-01-198.32
1997-01-108.42
2006-10-288.23
2007-04-168.91
2008-12-128.21
2011-08-28Tropical Storm Irene8.12
2012-10-29Hurricane Sandy9.19
2018-03-037.74
2022-01-177.71
2022-12-239.10
2023-12-189.12
2024-01-107.95
2024-01-138.30
2024-03-107.72

Dates are days where NOAA publishes the daily high tides (from 1977, except 1978). * Month only: NOAA's monthly highest water, where daily tides aren't published. † The gauge was not recording; 16.5 ft is the Coastal Resources Management Council's figure (Metro Bay plan, 2009 draft).

Days a year above the trigger, on the Corps' sea-level curves

YearLowIntermediateHigh
20300.60.71.1
20500.91.720.2
20701.26.4167.2
21003.650.7364.5

Tide heights from 2007–2025 replayed on each curve's sea level; trigger unchanged since design. These are days the water tops 7.68 feet, not closures: from 2010 through 2024 the Corps closed the gates for flood control 114 times against 9 such days. Closures: U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, New England District, Fox Point operation summaries 2010–2025, released under the Freedom of Information Act, October 2026.

Every time the gates closed, 2010–2025

The Corps took over the barrier in 2010. Its operation summaries list 190 closures since: 114 for flood control, 47 for WaterFire and 29 tests. Levels are feet above mean lower low water, as the Corps printed them.

YearFlood controlWaterFireTestFlood-control hours closedHighest water outside
2010150047.17.5
2011135742.48.39
2012147660.59.47
20134268.46.87
20142625.47.19
201576223.67.69
2016164049.87.76
201766018.87.17
2018104032.97.81
201965014.67.06
202070120.27.34
202160015.87.79
202230013.29.38
2023212—9.37
202431215.38.49
2025001——

U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, New England District, Fox Point operation summaries 2010–2025, released under the Freedom of Information Act, October 2026. One May 2017 closure was flood control combined with a WaterFire event; it is counted as flood control. 2023’s sheet gives no times. Every operation: fox-point-closures-2010-2025.csv (a flag column marks rows the sheets leave unclear); by year: fox-point-closures-by-year.csv.

When the rivers and the sea arrive together

The barrier holds back the sea, not the rivers. With the gates shut, the Woonasquatucket and the Moshassuck keep running into the basin behind them, and the Corps pumps that water over the barrier into the bay. The water inside the line rises with the rivers until the pumps catch up or the tide falls. Added October 7, 2026.

The two arrive together far more often than chance. Since 1977 the harbor at Providence has reached 7.0 feet above mean lower low water on 81 days. On 20 of them the Woonasquatucket at Centerdale was in its top 1% of daily flow, the same day or a day either side; on 24, the Moshassuck. If the two were independent, even allowing for both running high in winter and spring, two or three of each would be expected: the joint days come about ten times as often. The storms that raise the harbor, mostly nor’easters, are the storms that fill the rivers. Where a river meets the coast, FEMA’s mapping guidance combines the two sources’ rates of occurrence; behind an accredited levee, the question goes instead to an analysis of interior drainage.

Harbor at 7.0 ft or more with the Woonasquatucket in its top 1%Days
1980s1
1990s2
2000s6
2010s5
2020s, through August 20267

Raw counts, not rates; the tide record has gaps before 1980. Tides: NOAA gauge 8454000, verified high and low water, 1977 through August 2026. Flow: USGS daily mean discharge, Woonasquatucket River at Centerdale (01114500) and Moshassuck River at Providence (01114000).

The closures with the most river water or the highest water inside

ClosureOutside peak, ft MLLWInside peak, ft MLLWInside, ft NAVD88Gauged river inflow, cfsPumpsRain, in
March 30, 20107.506.804.333,13035.32
January 16, 20217.797.605.1333111.34
December 18, 20239.377.144.671,68232.43
January 10, 20248.447.284.811,96432.50
January 13, 20248.496.924.451,35851.99

Of 114 flood-control closures logged 2010–2025. Levels, pumps: U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Fox Point operation summaries, released under the Freedom of Information Act, October 2026. Inflow: USGS daily mean, same gauges. Rain: NOAA, T.F. Green Airport daily total.

How high the inside water has come, against the ground it protects

Inside waterft MLLWft NAVD88Protected area under waterAcresMain roads and facilities reached
Jan. 10, 2024: the most river water of the big 2023–24 closures7.284.811.0%4river edges only; no main road
Highest inside level in the Corps log (Jan. 16, 2021)7.605.131%5river edges only; no main road
8.005.531%5river edges only; no main road
8.506.031%6river edges only; no main road
9.006.534%16South Water Street, Dyer Street
9.507.036%23South Water Street, Dyer Street
10.007.538%35South Water Street, Dyer Street, Point Street, Eddy Street
10.508.0312%49Dyer Street, South Water Street, Point Street, Eddy Street, Memorial Boulevard
12.009.5327%112Dyer Street, Eddy Street, Canal Street, South Water Street, Point Street, Franklin Square Substation, Point Street Substation

MODEL. A connected bathtub on USGS 3DEP lidar at 2-meter cells: ground counts as under water if it lies below the level and connects through ground also below it to the rivers behind the barrier. Shares are of FEMA’s levee-credited area (about 420 acres). Not a hydraulic model: no flow rates, no timing, no storm drains, no buildings or basements. Through 12 feet, I-95 and I-195 stay above the water. Step through the levels with the inside-water control on the map at the top of the page.

At the highest level in the Corps’ log, the water reached about 1% of the protected area: the river edges. The next few feet matter more. By 9 feet it reaches South Water and Dyer Streets; by 10, Point and Eddy. By 12 feet it covers more than a quarter of the protected area, including stretches of Canal, Eddy and Point Streets and two electric substations, Franklin Square and Point Street. How much higher it could go depends on how fast the pumps move water against how fast the rivers bring it, and on how long the tide keeps the gates shut.

The pumps against the rivers

The barrier’s five pumps were designed to move 7,000 cubic feet a second, for the runoff of about 77 square miles behind it. The most river water to reach the barrier during any closure since 2010 came on March 30, 2010: the two gauged rivers’ peaks, scaled up to the full 77 square miles, come to about 4,800 cubic feet a second, 69% of design capacity. Four of the five pumps would have covered it. The Corps ran three. Added October 8, 2026.

River water does not set the level inside. Across the 114 closures, the inside peak and the inflow barely move together. The highest water inside in the log, 7.6 feet on January 16, 2021, came with 331 cubic feet a second coming in and one pump running. One pump ran in 86 of the 114 closures. At the flows seen since 2010, the water inside depends less on what the pumps can do than on when they are started and whether they keep running.

Design capacity: John Wm. Leslie, Chief of Engineering, Corps New England Division, Journal of the Boston Society of Civil Engineers 49(2), 1961. It is a design figure at design head; we have asked the Corps for the pumps’ present condition. Inflow scaled from the Woonasquatucket and Moshassuck gauges by drainage area (MODEL); storm drains that enter below the gauges are counted only through that scaling. Correlation of inside peak with inflow across the 114 closures: r = 0.2.

The Moshassuck, which runs through Smith Hill and downtown, set its record discharge, 2,200 cubic feet a second, on March 23, 2024; the National Weather Service has no flood stage for it.

What the flood map shows behind the line

FEMA’s map draws no flood zone of its own inside the credited area. The river zones stop at its edge, and the ground behind the barrier is shaded zone X. Federal rules allow that only after an analysis of interior drainage: where the water inside comes from, how far it spreads, and, if it averages more than a foot deep, the elevation of the 1%-a-year flood inside. That analysis has to rest on the joint probability of flooding inside and outside the line and on what the pumps and drains can carry away. Ponding deeper than a foot is mapped as its own zone. We have not found the interior-drainage analysis behind Providence’s map among published records. At the levels the Corps has logged, the model above agrees with the map: about 1% of the area wet, at the river edges. Added October 11, 2026.

Interior drainage: 44 CFR 65.10(b)(6). Coastal and river flooding combined: FEMA, Guidance for Flood Risk Analysis and Mapping: Combined Coastal and Riverine Floodplain, Guidance Document No. 32, November 2023. Zones: FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer, Providence County (44007C); no A, AE, AH or VE area lies inside the levee-credited polygons.

Who pays for flood insurance

FEMA’s map puts the ground behind the barrier in zone X: reduced risk, no federal requirement to insure. In May 2026, 589 flood policies were in force in all of Providence. 329 of them sat in zone X in the census block groups behind the barrier, at a median cost of $4,120 a year, more than the median A-zone policy. One of those 329 was on someone’s primary residence. Added October 8, 2026.

ZonePoliciesMedian cost a yearOn a primary residence
A, the 1%-a-year flood zone153$3,68615
V, coastal high hazard4$2,1830
X, in the block groups behind the barrier329$4,1201
X, the rest of the city104$72665

Policies in force May 1, 2026; a condominium master policy counts each unit. Cost is premium plus fees and surcharges. “Behind the barrier” means the six 2020 census block groups whose Census internal point falls inside FEMA’s levee-credited area; each policy is placed by the block group FEMA records for it. That is coarser than the parcel rings above. FEMA, OpenFEMA NFIP policies (NfipPolicies v3, as of September 8, 2026). Updated October 8, 2026: first published by census tract, which put 336 policies at a median $3,382 behind the barrier.

The city’s insured homes are elsewhere. 65 of the 104 X-zone policies elsewhere in the city are on primary residences; the median X-zone policy there costs $726. Of Providence’s 356 flood claims on record, 135 were on X-zone property; together the claims paid $13.9 million.

What homeowners pay, before and after Risk Rating 2.0

Primary residences20192021202320252019–2025
Providence$534$633$722$633+19%
East Providence$534$633$878$1,005+88%
Cranston$591$633$958$1,202+103%
New Bedford$879$974$991$1,132+29%

Median policy cost of policies taking effect each year, primary residences only. FEMA began pricing new policies under Risk Rating 2.0 in October 2021 and renewals in April 2022; most annual increases are capped at 18%. Pawtucket has too few insured homes a year to read. Claims: OpenFEMA NFIP claims (v3), all years, as of September 8, 2026.

Providence homeowners’ premiums rose 19% over six years. In East Providence and Cranston they roughly doubled. Part of it is where the homes are: 83% of Providence’s insured homes are in zone X, against 63% in East Providence and 42% in Cranston. But X-zone homes in Providence also pay less than X-zone homes next door: a median $612 on policies taking effect in 2025, against $811 in East Providence and $985 in Cranston.

What it costs to run

The Army Corps' New England District operates the barrier. The Corps' work plan for fiscal 2026 allots $6,348,000 to Fox Point for operation and maintenance. The President's budget had asked for $698,000; the figure Congress set in its explanatory statement, and the Corps allotted, is nine times that. Beyond routine work, the plan names two jobs: replacing the electrical switchgear and repairing the mechanical systems of the river pumps.

US Army Corps of Engineers, Civil Works, FY 2026 Work Plan, Operation and Maintenance, p. 23. The plan's illustrative breakout puts $2,539,200 of the total to district salaries and expenses and $3,808,800 to the project itself.