Providence, on the record
Liam Freaney · reporting built on the public record

What Colleges and Hospitals Pay on Their Exempt Property, in Providence and in Boston

For every $1,000 of exempt property on the tax roll, the six Providence colleges and hospitals paid the City $3.00 in cash in fiscal 2025. Boston’s 38 PILOT institutions paid Boston $1.26. Boston also credits community programs against what it asks; counted that way, its figure is $3.64.

$3.00cash per $1,000 of exempt property, Providence, 6 institutions
$1.26cash per $1,000 of exempt property, Boston, 38 institutions
$5.93Brown University, the highest of the 44 in either city
$3.64Boston, counting the community-benefit credits it allows

These institutions hold $4.72B of exempt property in Providence and $28.09B in Boston. In cash, the Providence institutions paid $14.2M and the Boston institutions $35.5M. Brown paid $11.1M on $1.87B, or $5.93 per $1,000. Of Boston’s four largest holders, Massachusetts General Hospital paid $1.86, Boston University paid $1.53, Harvard University paid $1.10, Northeastern University paid $0.62. Counting Boston’s credits, four Boston institutions come out above Brown’s cash figure: Spaulding Rehabilitation Hospital, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, GBH (WGBH), Massachusetts Eye & Ear Infirmary.

Every institution, ranked by cash per $1,000 of exempt property

InstitutionCityExempt property on the rollCash paidPer $1,000Per $1,000 with Boston’s creditBoston’s own % metTax billed on its taxable parcels
Brown UniversityProvidence$1.87B$11.1M$5.93——$1.5M
Spaulding Rehabilitation HospitalBoston$102.0M$581,000$5.70$12.3090%$0
Beth Israel Deaconess Medical CenterBoston$1.17B$3.9M$3.31$6.62100%$332,000
GBH (WGBH)Boston$56.8M$169,000$2.98$5.95100%$330,000
Massachusetts Eye & Ear InfirmaryBoston$155.6M$436,000$2.80$5.9894%$56,000
Dana-Farber Cancer InstituteBoston$668.0M$1.7M$2.53$5.07100%$215,000
Massachusetts College of PharmacyBoston$234.2M$457,000$1.95$3.90100%$141,000
Massachusetts General HospitalBoston$3.69B$6.9M$1.86$4.1990%$2.0M
Showa InstituteBoston$55.8M$102,000$1.83$3.66100%$176,000
Longwood CollectiveBoston$97.7M$174,000$1.78$3.57100%$202,000
Suffolk UniversityBoston$339.4M$573,000$1.69$4.8277%$205,000
New England Baptist HospitalBoston$222.5M$371,000$1.67$4.2283%$301,000
Boston UniversityBoston$4.11B$6.3M$1.53$4.5577%$2.6M
Faulkner Brigham and Women'sBoston$374.9M$570,000$1.52$3.4290%$175,000
RISDProvidence$411.0M$612,000$1.49——$0
Johnson & WalesProvidence$421.5M$612,000$1.45——$0
New England College of OptometryBoston$33.7M$49,000$1.45$2.89100%$0
Tufts UniversityBoston$325.5M$450,000$1.38$3.4084%$30,000
Brigham and Women's HospitalBoston$2.33B$3.0M$1.30$2.9789%$178,000
Providence CollegeProvidence$575.5M$740,000$1.29——$4,779
Boston Symphony OrchestraBoston$51.8M$63,000$1.22$2.44100%$74,000
Berklee College of MusicBoston$337.4M$385,000$1.14$3.4286%$638,000
Harvard UniversityBoston$3.86B$4.2M$1.10$2.9979%$10.3M
Boston Children's HospitalBoston$2.06B$2.2M$1.06$4.79100%$125,000
Boston Architectural CollegeBoston$19.1M$20,000$1.03$2.06100%$0
Care New EnglandProvidence$385.6M$350,000$0.91——$0
Hebrew Rehabilitation CenterBoston$43.5M$35,000$0.80$3.7863%$23,000
Brown University HealthProvidence$1.06B$750,000$0.71——$141,000
Northeastern UniversityBoston$3.07B$1.9M$0.62$2.8666%$2.5M
Boston CollegeBoston$800.2M$439,000$0.55$0.5522%$977,000
Emmanuel CollegeBoston$394.7M$170,000$0.43$2.6460%$0
Emerson CollegeBoston$452.2M$142,000$0.31$3.0056%$543,000
Simmons UniversityBoston$362.0M$100,000$0.28$1.9558%$313,000
Tufts Medical CenterBoston$615.6M$150,000$0.24$3.6154%$165,000
Boston Medical CenterBoston$790.8M$0$0.00$2.1375%$1.4M
Wentworth Institute of TechnologyBoston$368.9M$0$0.00$2.6050%$15,000
Shriners Hospitals for Children BostonBoston$214.9M$0$0.00$0.000%$0
Joslin Diabetes CenterBoston$171.7M$0$0.00$0.000%$164,000
Franciscan Children's HospitalBoston$142.7M$0$0.00$1.2050%$0
Winsor SchoolBoston$85.0M$0$0.00$1.5050%$0
New England ConservatoryBoston$81.2M$0$0.00$0.8850%$28,000
Roxbury Latin SchoolBoston$74.3M$0$0.00$2.4750%$171,000
Fisher CollegeBoston$66.0M$0$0.00$2.0450%$142,000
Boston College High SchoolBoston$54.2M$0$0.00$1.0950%$0

Providence rows are shaded. Exempt property is the assessed value of fully exempt parcels the roll lists under the institution’s name. Cash is what the institution paid the City in fiscal 2025 (July 2024 through June 2025) under its agreement or, in Boston, the PILOT program. Boston’s “% met” is the City’s own measure, cash plus credit against what it asked. The last column is ordinary property tax on parcels the institution owns that are not exempt; it is not part of the payment. Care New England’s payment is the latest on record, for fiscal 2024.

Five years of Boston’s PILOT, FY2021 to FY2025

Fiscal yearInstitutionsAskedCredited for community programsPaid in cashCash as share of ask
FY202147$120.2M$55.4M$35.1M29%
FY202247$123.6M$56.8M$35.5M29%
FY202345$128.6M$62.1M$35.7M28%
FY202438$128.8M$63.7M$34.9M27%
FY202538$133.6M$66.6M$35.5M27%

What Boston asks has risen every year; cash has not. The ask grew from $120.2M to $133.6M, while cash stayed near $35 million. The difference was made up in credits. Six museums left the table in FY2024, when the City moved them to what its recap calls “an alternative system” of reporting community benefits, so the earlier years count more institutions.

The valuation behind the asks has barely moved. For 25 of the 38 institutions listed in all five years, the City’s value basis is the same to the dollar in FY2021 and FY2025: Berklee College of Music at $173.9M, Boston College at $536.1M, Emerson College at $266.7M. Their asks rose about 2.5% a year all the same. The recaps do not say what year’s values the basis comes from.

Since fiscal 2025: two new agreements

Neither agreement mentions a value basis or the quarter-of-the-tax ask. Each sets a fixed schedule of cash, as Providence’s agreements with its colleges do. Boston University’s agreement “shall supersede and replace any and all previous agreements” on payments in lieu of taxes; Wentworth’s replaces its arrangements under the 2010 Task Force report. The table above still shows fiscal 2025, the last year both were under the old program.

How Boston asks

Boston asks every nonprofit holding more than $15 million in property to pay a quarter of what it would owe if the property were taxed, the share of the City’s budget its 2010 PILOT Task Force tied to police, fire, snow removal and other basic services. Generally up to half of that request can be met with community programs the City credits as directly benefiting Boston residents. The City sets each institution’s request on a “value basis” of its own and publishes the request, the cash, the credit and the share met every year. Providence has no formula. Each institution’s payment is set by its own agreement with the City, and the State separately reimburses the City for part of the tax it does not collect from colleges and hospitals. Massachusetts has no such payment for private colleges and hospitals.

What doesn’t line up

Not yet on the record

Data

compare_pvd_bos.csv · institutions_pvd_2025_v0.3.csv · institutions_bos_2026_v0.2.csv · pilot_history_bos_v0.2.csv · agreement_schedules_bos_v0.2.csv

Sources: City of Providence 2025 tax roll and payment agreements; City of Boston FY2026 Property Assessment file (data.boston.gov) PILOT Recaps, FY2021 through FY2025, and its 2026 agreements with Boston University and Wentworth Institute of Technology; City of Boston PILOT Task Force final report, 2010. Built from Off the Roll v0.3 (Providence) and v0.2 (Boston). Data licensed CC BY 4.0: credit “Providence, on the record.”