Providence, on the record
Liam Freaney · reporting built on the public record

Who Pays for the Sewer

Every Providence home pays the Narragansett Bay Commission $309.87 a year per apartment before using a drop of water. About half of what the bill raises goes to debt, and the biggest debt is the combined-sewer tunnel now estimated at $1.4 billion. The Commission has no discount for households that can’t pay, and it can have their water shut off.

$638a year, the average residential bill, July 2026
49%of it is the fixed charge per apartment
41%of what the Commission raises goes to principal and interest; 51% with required coverage
$1.4 billionthe Commission’s current figure for the Phase III overflow project, up from $678 million in 2014

The bill

Since July 1, 2026, a Providence home pays $309.87 a year for each dwelling unit, plus $4.972 for every hundred cubic feet of water used. At the Commission’s own average use, 5.5 hundred cubic feet a month, that comes to $638.02 a year, and the fixed charge is 49% of it. A three-family house owes $929.61 a year in fixed charges alone. The fixed charge is billed to the owner of the account, not to the tenant.

Rate yearPer unit per yearPer hundred cubic feetAverage billLight user MODEL
FY2017 (eff. Jul 1 2016)$218.80$3.531$451.85$345.92
FY2025$260.87$4.186$537.15$411.57
FY2026$286.04$4.590$588.98$451.28
FY2027$309.87$4.972$638.02$488.86

Residential tariffs, NBC Schedule A, FY2017–FY2027; FY2027 from PUC Docket 25-32-WW, Compliance Exhibits 2 and 3 (filed July 1, 2026). Average bill at 66 hundred cubic feet a year, the Commission’s average customer. Light user at 36 a year (3 a month) is an assumption: at that use the household pays $13.58 for each hundred cubic feet it uses, against $9.67 at average use.

What the bill pays for

The Public Utilities Commission set the Bay Commission’s revenue for fiscal 2027 at $137.85 million. The Commission had asked for an 11.35% increase; it got 8.3%.

Fiscal 2027DollarsShare
Principal$35,530,513
Interest$20,817,858
Debt service$56,348,37140.9%
Debt-service coverage, 1.25 times$14,087,09310.2%
Operating expenses$66,978,90548.6%

PUC Docket 25-32-WW, Compliance Exhibit 1 (filed July 1, 2026). Coverage is revenue lenders require above debt service. The Commission asked to raise it to 1.30 times; the PUC denied that without prejudice (Order 25601, Feb. 2, 2026).

The Commission carries about $1.2 billion in long-term debt and projects about $1.43 billion by fiscal 2035. Its capital needs through fiscal 2027 run $67.9 million past its sources, a gap to be filled by more borrowing. On the average bill, the debt share comes to about $261 a year, $326 with coverage MODEL.

Debt: PUC Order 25601, pp. 6–7. Capital gap: Division of Public Utilities memo, Nov. 14, 2025. Per-bill figure assumes residential bills carry debt in proportion to revenue.

Phase III

Phase III is the last stage of the Commission’s combined-sewer overflow program: a 2.2-mile tunnel under Pawtucket and Central Falls holding 58.5 million gallons, with interceptors, storage and sewer separation. Its stated cost has more than doubled.

WhenFigureWhat it coversSource
Oct. 2014$678 millionPhase IIINBC affordability presentation, Oct. 23, 2014
2014–15$750 millionPhase III, on a 2038 scheduleNBC Phase III re-evaluation
2019$548.4 millionPhase III facilities: tunnel, shafts, pump stationEPA WIFIA
Sept. 2021$813 millionPhase IIIAASCE Civil Engineering
Dec. 2025$1.4 billion“CSO project Phase 3”; about $850 million spent by the tunnel’s start, Feb. 2028NBC testimony, PUC Order 25601, p. 6

Phase III is about half of the Commission’s $511.9 million capital plan for fiscal 2026–31. The record does not say how much of the $56.3 million in annual debt service it accounts for; that has been asked of the Commission.

Capital plan: Bowen testimony, Order 25601, p. 4. The figures above measure different scopes and are not adjusted for inflation.

What it buys

At full build-out, EPA projects 98% less overflow volume and 80% fewer shellfish-bed closures; overflows would fall from 80 to 90 a year to about four. The Commission’s own 2014 model of days the water fails its standard, after Phase III against after Phase II:

WaterUseChange
Upper bay, Area BShellfishing−100%
Upper bay, Area AShellfishing−82%
Providence River (SB)Shellfishing−79%
Conimicut TriangleShellfishing−60%
Providence River (SB1)Swimming−36%
Seekonk River (SB1)Swimming−16%

Acre-days not meeting standard, post-Phase II to post-Phase III (2038), NBC Phase III re-evaluation, 2014–15. EPA WIFIA project page; ASCE Civil Engineering, Sept. 2021. These are projections, not yet checked against RIDEM’s closure records, which have been requested.

Who can’t pay

The Commission has no low-income discount, tiered rate or hardship credit. A customer who can’t pay on time may ask for a payment arrangement. Late balances carry 1% interest a month. Under state law the Commission can order a customer’s water supplier to shut off the water within 14 days for an unpaid sewer bill; a tenant who pays to restore service may deduct it from the rent.

NBC tariffs, FY2027 Schedules A and B; 835-RICR-20-00-2.16; NBC, Pay Your Bill; R.I. Gen. Laws § 46-25-22.1; NBC, Water Shut-Off.

The Commission measured the burden itself in 2014. Following EPA guidance, it counted households paying more than 2% of income for sewer: with Phase III, 64,046 across its service area, 29,067 of them in Providence. It then set a target bill of $626 a year. The fiscal 2027 average bill is $638.

NBC affordability presentation, Oct. 23, 2014; NBC Phase III re-evaluation, 2014–15. The $626 target is in 2014 dollars.

Today, the average bill passes 2% of income for any Providence household earning less than about $31,900. By the Census Bureau’s count, 2,725 owner households and 13,134 renter households fall entirely below that line MODEL.

Household incomeOwnersRentersAverage bill as share of income
<$5k6673,07025.5%
$5–10k2651,5308.5%
$10–15k3934,5315.1%
$15–20k5782,3423.6%
$20–25k8221,6612.8%
$25–35k1,4092,8172.1%
$35–50k2,6644,6101.5%
$50–75k3,9907,8521.0%
$75–100k3,9965,3030.7%
$100–150k5,4534,7290.5%
$150k+9,3643,4510.3%

Households: American Community Survey 2020–2024, table B25118, Providence. Share of income at each bracket’s midpoint, at average use. A renter’s share assumes the bill reaches the tenant in full through the rent; there is no Providence record of how much does.

A 50% discount for Providence households under $25,000 would cost about $5.06 million a year. Spread across the Commission’s residential units, that adds about $42.63 a unit, 6.7% on the average bill MODEL.

15,859 households × $638.02 × 50%, over 118,683 residential units, the Commission’s 2014 count, the latest in hand. Providence only; Pawtucket and Central Falls households would add to it.

Asked of the Commission

Data: tariffs (CSV), burden by income (CSV).