Who Pays for the Sewer
Every Providence home pays the Narragansett Bay Commission $309.87 a year per apartment before using a drop of water. About half of what the bill raises goes to debt, and the biggest debt is the combined-sewer tunnel now estimated at $1.4 billion. The Commission has no discount for households that can’t pay, and it can have their water shut off.
The bill
Since July 1, 2026, a Providence home pays $309.87 a year for each dwelling unit, plus $4.972 for every hundred cubic feet of water used. At the Commission’s own average use, 5.5 hundred cubic feet a month, that comes to $638.02 a year, and the fixed charge is 49% of it. A three-family house owes $929.61 a year in fixed charges alone. The fixed charge is billed to the owner of the account, not to the tenant.
| Rate year | Per unit per year | Per hundred cubic feet | Average bill | Light user MODEL |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| FY2017 (eff. Jul 1 2016) | $218.80 | $3.531 | $451.85 | $345.92 |
| FY2025 | $260.87 | $4.186 | $537.15 | $411.57 |
| FY2026 | $286.04 | $4.590 | $588.98 | $451.28 |
| FY2027 | $309.87 | $4.972 | $638.02 | $488.86 |
Residential tariffs, NBC Schedule A, FY2017–FY2027; FY2027 from PUC Docket 25-32-WW, Compliance Exhibits 2 and 3 (filed July 1, 2026). Average bill at 66 hundred cubic feet a year, the Commission’s average customer. Light user at 36 a year (3 a month) is an assumption: at that use the household pays $13.58 for each hundred cubic feet it uses, against $9.67 at average use.
What the bill pays for
The Public Utilities Commission set the Bay Commission’s revenue for fiscal 2027 at $137.85 million. The Commission had asked for an 11.35% increase; it got 8.3%.
| Fiscal 2027 | Dollars | Share |
|---|---|---|
| Principal | $35,530,513 | |
| Interest | $20,817,858 | |
| Debt service | $56,348,371 | 40.9% |
| Debt-service coverage, 1.25 times | $14,087,093 | 10.2% |
| Operating expenses | $66,978,905 | 48.6% |
PUC Docket 25-32-WW, Compliance Exhibit 1 (filed July 1, 2026). Coverage is revenue lenders require above debt service. The Commission asked to raise it to 1.30 times; the PUC denied that without prejudice (Order 25601, Feb. 2, 2026).
The Commission carries about $1.2 billion in long-term debt and projects about $1.43 billion by fiscal 2035. Its capital needs through fiscal 2027 run $67.9 million past its sources, a gap to be filled by more borrowing. On the average bill, the debt share comes to about $261 a year, $326 with coverage MODEL.
Debt: PUC Order 25601, pp. 6–7. Capital gap: Division of Public Utilities memo, Nov. 14, 2025. Per-bill figure assumes residential bills carry debt in proportion to revenue.
Phase III
Phase III is the last stage of the Commission’s combined-sewer overflow program: a 2.2-mile tunnel under Pawtucket and Central Falls holding 58.5 million gallons, with interceptors, storage and sewer separation. Its stated cost has more than doubled.
| When | Figure | What it covers | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Oct. 2014 | $678 million | Phase III | NBC affordability presentation, Oct. 23, 2014 |
| 2014–15 | $750 million | Phase III, on a 2038 schedule | NBC Phase III re-evaluation |
| 2019 | $548.4 million | Phase III facilities: tunnel, shafts, pump station | EPA WIFIA |
| Sept. 2021 | $813 million | Phase IIIA | ASCE Civil Engineering |
| Dec. 2025 | $1.4 billion | “CSO project Phase 3”; about $850 million spent by the tunnel’s start, Feb. 2028 | NBC testimony, PUC Order 25601, p. 6 |
Phase III is about half of the Commission’s $511.9 million capital plan for fiscal 2026–31. The record does not say how much of the $56.3 million in annual debt service it accounts for; that has been asked of the Commission.
Capital plan: Bowen testimony, Order 25601, p. 4. The figures above measure different scopes and are not adjusted for inflation.
What it buys
At full build-out, EPA projects 98% less overflow volume and 80% fewer shellfish-bed closures; overflows would fall from 80 to 90 a year to about four. The Commission’s own 2014 model of days the water fails its standard, after Phase III against after Phase II:
| Water | Use | Change |
|---|---|---|
| Upper bay, Area B | Shellfishing | −100% |
| Upper bay, Area A | Shellfishing | −82% |
| Providence River (SB) | Shellfishing | −79% |
| Conimicut Triangle | Shellfishing | −60% |
| Providence River (SB1) | Swimming | −36% |
| Seekonk River (SB1) | Swimming | −16% |
Acre-days not meeting standard, post-Phase II to post-Phase III (2038), NBC Phase III re-evaluation, 2014–15. EPA WIFIA project page; ASCE Civil Engineering, Sept. 2021. These are projections, not yet checked against RIDEM’s closure records, which have been requested.
Who can’t pay
The Commission has no low-income discount, tiered rate or hardship credit. A customer who can’t pay on time may ask for a payment arrangement. Late balances carry 1% interest a month. Under state law the Commission can order a customer’s water supplier to shut off the water within 14 days for an unpaid sewer bill; a tenant who pays to restore service may deduct it from the rent.
NBC tariffs, FY2027 Schedules A and B; 835-RICR-20-00-2.16; NBC, Pay Your Bill; R.I. Gen. Laws § 46-25-22.1; NBC, Water Shut-Off.
The Commission measured the burden itself in 2014. Following EPA guidance, it counted households paying more than 2% of income for sewer: with Phase III, 64,046 across its service area, 29,067 of them in Providence. It then set a target bill of $626 a year. The fiscal 2027 average bill is $638.
NBC affordability presentation, Oct. 23, 2014; NBC Phase III re-evaluation, 2014–15. The $626 target is in 2014 dollars.
Today, the average bill passes 2% of income for any Providence household earning less than about $31,900. By the Census Bureau’s count, 2,725 owner households and 13,134 renter households fall entirely below that line MODEL.
| Household income | Owners | Renters | Average bill as share of income |
|---|---|---|---|
| <$5k | 667 | 3,070 | 25.5% |
| $5–10k | 265 | 1,530 | 8.5% |
| $10–15k | 393 | 4,531 | 5.1% |
| $15–20k | 578 | 2,342 | 3.6% |
| $20–25k | 822 | 1,661 | 2.8% |
| $25–35k | 1,409 | 2,817 | 2.1% |
| $35–50k | 2,664 | 4,610 | 1.5% |
| $50–75k | 3,990 | 7,852 | 1.0% |
| $75–100k | 3,996 | 5,303 | 0.7% |
| $100–150k | 5,453 | 4,729 | 0.5% |
| $150k+ | 9,364 | 3,451 | 0.3% |
Households: American Community Survey 2020–2024, table B25118, Providence. Share of income at each bracket’s midpoint, at average use. A renter’s share assumes the bill reaches the tenant in full through the rent; there is no Providence record of how much does.
A 50% discount for Providence households under $25,000 would cost about $5.06 million a year. Spread across the Commission’s residential units, that adds about $42.63 a unit, 6.7% on the average bill MODEL.
15,859 households × $638.02 × 50%, over 118,683 residential units, the Commission’s 2014 count, the latest in hand. Providence only; Pawtucket and Central Falls households would add to it.
Asked of the Commission
- Phase III’s share of fiscal 2027 debt service, and of the $1.2 billion outstanding.
- Whether $1.4 billion covers Phases IIIA through IIID, and spending on Phase III to date.
- Water shutoffs ordered for unpaid sewer bills, by year and city.
- Whether the Commission has costed a low-income rate since 2014.
- Overflow events by outfall since 2015, requested under the Access to Public Records Act, Oct. 7, 2026.
Data: tariffs (CSV), burden by income (CSV).