Asked and Paid: Providence’s Agreements on Boston’s Terms
Boston asks its colleges and hospitals for a quarter of the tax their exempt property would owe. Asked that way, on the 2025 roll at Providence’s commercial rate, Providence’s six paying colleges and hospitals would be asked $34.5M a year. Under their agreements they paid $14.2M, 41% of it. Boston asked its 38 institutions $133.6M in fiscal 2025 and was paid $35.5M in cash, 27%; the rest was met in credited community programs or not at all.
Providence: the six that pay, on Boston’s terms
Exempt value is the assessed value of fully exempt parcels the 2025 roll lists under the institution. The tax at full rate prices it at the commercial rate the roll bills, $29.20 per $1,000. Boston’s formula asks a quarter of that. The last two columns are what the institution actually paid the City under its agreement, and that payment as a share of the formula ask.
| Institution | Exempt value on the roll | Tax at full rate | A quarter of it (Boston’s ask) | Paid under agreement | Paid as share of ask |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Brown University | $1.87B | $54.6M | $13.7M | $11.1M | 81% |
| Brown University Health | $1.06B | $30.8M | $7.7M | $750,000 | 10% |
| Providence College | $575.5M | $16.8M | $4.2M | $740,000 | 18% |
| Johnson & Wales | $421.5M | $12.3M | $3.1M | $612,000 | 20% |
| RISD | $411.0M | $12.0M | $3.0M | $612,000 | 20% |
| Care New England | $385.6M | $11.3M | $2.8M | $350,000 (2024) | 12% |
| Six institutions | $4.72B | $137.8M | $34.5M | $14.2M | 41% |
| Providence Place (not a nonprofit; exempt by Council vote) | $730.8M | $21.3M | $5.3M | $1.0M (approx.) | 19% |
Payments: Brown, $11.1 million in direct voluntary payments in fiscal 2025 (Brown’s Community Contributions report; Brown Daily Herald, Dec. 2025). RISD, Providence College and Johnson & Wales, the fiscal 2025 payments scheduled in Exhibit A of the 2023 agreement. Brown University Health, $750,000 under the agreement signed Nov. 15, 2024. Care New England, $350,000 in 2024, the latest on record (Boston Globe, Oct. 1, 2024). Providence Place, about $1 million a year under its agreement (Boston Globe, Apr. 30 and Aug. 20, 2026); the mall is shown because it has an agreement, not because Boston’s program would reach it. The State separately paid Providence $37.3 million in fiscal 2025 for the tax its colleges and hospitals do not pay; that is not in this table, and Massachusetts makes no such payment to Boston.
Who else Boston’s line would reach
Boston asks every educational, medical and cultural nonprofit holding more than $15 million in property, so its 38 include day schools, a conservatory, an orchestra and a public broadcaster. On Providence’s roll these nonprofits hold more than $15 million of exempt property and have no payment agreement with the City. Religious owners are left out, as Boston leaves them out.
| Owner on the roll | Kind | Exempt value | A quarter of the tax at full rate |
|---|---|---|---|
| Providence Public Library | library | $61.7M | $450,000 |
| New England Yearly Meeting of Friends (Moses Brown School) | school | $45.7M | $334,000 |
| Wheeler School | school | $38.1M | $278,000 |
| Meeting Street | school | $30.1M | $220,000 |
| Times2 STEM Academy | charter school | $20.8M | $152,000 |
| Providence Community Health Centers (two spellings on the roll, combined here; it pays $150,000 a year under a stabilization agreement on another parcel (Beaman and Smith Mill)) | health center | $20.2M | $147,000 |
| Boys & Girls Clubs of Providence | youth | $15.0M | $110,000 |
| 7 owners | $231.6M | $1.7M |
Owners are named from the roll’s owner strings; the roll does not type them, so this is the set that can be classified by name. Rhode Island Health and Educational Building Corporation, a state financing agency, holds $38.5 million of exempt property as a conduit for the nonprofits it finances and is not listed.
Boston: the 38, on the same terms
Boston publishes what it asked, on a “value basis” it sets itself, and what each institution paid in cash and in credited community programs. Beside the City’s own ask is what the same formula gives on Boston’s FY2026 roll: a quarter of the tax on the exempt value listed under the institution, at the commercial rate the roll bills, $26.96 per $1,000.
| Institution | Exempt value on the roll | City’s value basis | City asked (FY25) | A quarter of the tax on the roll | Paid in cash | Credited | City’s % met |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Boston University | $4.11B | $2.62B | $24.8M | $27.7M | $6.3M | $12.4M | 77% |
| Harvard University | $3.86B | $1.52B | $14.6M | $26.0M | $4.2M | $7.3M | 79% |
| Massachusetts General Hospital | $3.69B | $1.79B | $17.2M | $24.9M | $6.9M | $8.6M | 90% |
| Northeastern University | $3.07B | $1.44B | $13.8M | $20.7M | $1.9M | $6.9M | 66% |
| Brigham and Women's Hospital | $2.33B | $820.2M | $7.8M | $15.7M | $3.0M | $3.9M | 89% |
| Boston Children's Hospital | $2.06B | $1.15B | $10.3M | $13.9M | $2.2M | $7.7M | 100% |
| Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center | $1.17B | $816.8M | $7.8M | $7.9M | $3.9M | $3.9M | 100% |
| Boston College | $800.2M | $536.1M | $5.1M | $5.4M | $439,000 | $0 | 22% |
| Boston Medical Center | $790.8M | $283.4M | $2.2M | $5.3M | $0 | $1.7M | 75% |
| Dana-Farber Cancer Institute | $668.0M | $373.3M | $3.4M | $4.5M | $1.7M | $1.7M | 100% |
| Tufts Medical Center | $615.6M | $456.8M | $4.1M | $4.1M | $150,000 | $2.1M | 54% |
| Emerson College | $452.2M | $266.7M | $2.4M | $3.0M | $142,000 | $1.2M | 56% |
| Emmanuel College | $394.7M | $194.6M | $1.7M | $2.7M | $170,000 | $870,000 | 60% |
| Faulkner Brigham and Women's | $374.9M | $162.0M | $1.4M | $2.5M | $570,000 | $712,000 | 90% |
| Wentworth Institute of Technology | $368.9M | $213.8M | $1.9M | $2.5M | $0 | $958,000 | 50% |
| Simmons University | $362.0M | $139.7M | $1.2M | $2.4M | $100,000 | $604,000 | 58% |
| Suffolk University | $339.4M | $242.9M | $2.1M | $2.3M | $573,000 | $1.1M | 77% |
| Berklee College of Music | $337.4M | $173.9M | $1.5M | $2.3M | $385,000 | $770,000 | 86% |
| Tufts University | $325.5M | $151.4M | $1.3M | $2.2M | $450,000 | $655,000 | 84% |
| Massachusetts College of Pharmacy | $234.2M | $109.3M | $914,000 | $1.6M | $457,000 | $457,000 | 100% |
| New England Baptist Hospital | $222.5M | $132.2M | $1.1M | $1.5M | $371,000 | $568,000 | 83% |
| Shriners Hospitals for Children Boston | $214.9M | $106.1M | $883,000 | $1.4M | $0 | $0 | 0% |
| Joslin Diabetes Center | $171.7M | $86.3M | $691,000 | $1.2M | $0 | $0 | 0% |
| Massachusetts Eye & Ear Infirmary | $155.6M | $116.9M | $988,000 | $1.0M | $436,000 | $494,000 | 94% |
| Franciscan Children's Hospital | $142.7M | $50.4M | $343,000 | $962,000 | $0 | $172,000 | 50% |
| Spaulding Rehabilitation Hospital | $102.0M | $159.4M | $1.4M | $687,000 | $581,000 | $673,000 | 90% |
| Longwood Collective | $97.7M | $50.9M | $348,000 | $659,000 | $174,000 | $174,000 | 100% |
| Winsor School | $85.0M | $41.3M | $255,000 | $573,000 | $0 | $127,000 | 50% |
| New England Conservatory | $81.2M | $29.7M | $143,000 | $547,000 | $0 | $71,000 | 50% |
| Roxbury Latin School | $74.3M | $52.9M | $367,000 | $501,000 | $0 | $184,000 | 50% |
| Fisher College | $66.0M | $42.8M | $270,000 | $445,000 | $0 | $135,000 | 50% |
| GBH (WGBH) | $56.8M | $49.9M | $338,000 | $383,000 | $169,000 | $169,000 | 100% |
| Showa Institute | $55.8M | $36.1M | $204,000 | $376,000 | $102,000 | $102,000 | 100% |
| Boston College High School | $54.2M | $27.2M | $118,000 | $365,000 | $0 | $59,000 | 50% |
| Boston Symphony Orchestra | $51.8M | $28.1M | $127,000 | $349,000 | $63,000 | $63,000 | 100% |
| Hebrew Rehabilitation Center | $43.5M | $41.7M | $259,000 | $293,000 | $35,000 | $130,000 | 63% |
| New England College of Optometry | $33.7M | $25.1M | $98,000 | $227,000 | $49,000 | $49,000 | 100% |
| Boston Architectural College | $19.1M | $19.1M | $39,000 | $129,000 | $20,000 | $20,000 | 100% |
| 38 institutions | $28.09B | $14.56B | $133.6M | $189.3M | $35.5M | $66.6M | 76% |
City of Boston FY25 PILOT Recap (Apr. 1, 2026) and FY2026 Property Assessment file (data.boston.gov). The value basis is the City’s own figure and is not recomputed here. The City says it is the institutions’ fiscal 2011 values, set through the PILOT Task Force, and that the ask rises 2.5 percent a year, mirroring Proposition 2½ (City Records Co-op, answer to public records request R-2026-1799, Nov. 6, 2026). For most institutions the basis has not changed since FY2021 and runs well below exempt value on the roll (Off the Roll’s Providence and Boston page). On the roll, the formula would ask $189.3M against the City’s $133.6M; in cash the 38 paid $35.5M, 19% of the roll figure. Boston’s roll is fiscal 2026’s and values property as of Jan. 1, 2025; the recap is fiscal 2025’s.
Providence’s stabilization agreements: asked and billed
A tax stabilization agreement fixes a developer’s bill below the full rate for a set term. The City Internal Auditor’s FY2025 report lists 66 agreements covering $1.01B of property, billed $15.9M against $35.5M at the full rate, $19.6M abated in one year, at the 2024 rates ($35.10 commercial) before the 2025 revaluation. Those printed totals are the record. The rows below are the report’s exhibit pages, one per agreement, which add to within 0.1% of the printed bill; one agreement in the report’s index has no exhibit page and is carried as unconfirmed.
| Agreement | Assessed (2024) | Tax at full rate | Billed | Abated | Annual report filed |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CharterCare, Prospect CharterCare the report prints no full-rate column for this agreement; computed at $35.10 | $114.9M | $4.0M | $2.9M | $1.1M | Yes |
| Intercontinental Fund (Blue Cross & Blue Shield), 100-500 Exchange Street | $68.9M | $2.4M | $1.8M | $660,000 | No |
| TFG Providence Center Property LLC (10 Memorial Blvd Owner LLC), 10 Memorial Boulevard | $59.5M | $2.1M | $1.3M | $787,000 | No |
| EM 28 Providence Owner, L.P., 125 Clifford Street | $57.5M | $2.0M | $3,670 | $2.0M | Yes |
| Providence Innovation District Phase I, LLC, 225 Dyer Street | $49.6M | $1.7M | $253,000 | $1.5M | Yes |
| CV River House LLC, 11 Point Street | $44.5M | $1.6M | $293,000 | $1.3M | No |
| RP Providence Owner LLC, 1-5 Avenue of the Arts | $43.3M | $1.5M | $880,000 | $641,000 | Yes |
| 262 LLC, 80 Smith Street Admin | $41.1M | $1.4M | $649,000 | $795,000 | Yes |
| CV South Street Landing LLC, 350 Eddy Street | $38.8M | $1.4M | $434,000 | $928,000 | No |
| Sharpe Building Associates LLC (Promenade Street Owner LLC c/o DSF Advisors LLC), 25 Holden Street | $38.5M | $1.4M | $788,000 | $563,000 | No |
| 110 North Main Street LLC, 169 Canal Street | $34.6M | $1.2M | $443,000 | $772,000 | No |
| UNCONFIRMED McInnis USA Inc, 39 New York Avenue (Tangible), CC-15 UNCONFIRMED. Listed in the report's index with no exhibit page; these figures are what the printed Table 1 totals leave over once the other 65 are subtracted (within $33 on assessed value). Not yet confirmed by the Internal Auditor. | $31.7M | $1.1M | $16,000 | $1.1M | — |
| 78 Fountain JV Owner LLC, 78 Fountain Street | $30.3M | $1.1M | $326,000 | $738,000 | No |
| CC WCM-MP PO, LLC (CBWC Holdings I LLC), 180 Friendship | $25.6M | $898,000 | $102,000 | $796,000 | Yes |
| Biltmore Providence Owner LLC, 11 Dorrance Street | $24.2M | $850,000 | $125,000 | $726,000 | This is not a requirement for this property owner |
| 261, LLC, 80 Smith Street CC | $23.4M | $820,000 | $412,000 | $408,000 | Yes |
| Branch Holdings LLC, 745 Branch Avenue | $22.2M | $778,000 | $356,000 | $423,000 | Yes |
| BAC CVP Aloft, LLC, A Loft | $19.5M | $684,000 | $9,175 | $675,000 | Yes |
| Brown University, 342 Eddy Street holder as listed by the Internal Auditor; the Mayor's office said Oct. 7, 2026 that 342 Eddy is owned by Narragansett Electric, with about an acre leased to CV SSL Garage LLC, and that Brown owns only the upper level of 350 Eddy, which has no reporting requirement. Asked of the auditor. | $16.6M | $584,000 | $83,000 | $501,000 | No |
| Fogarty Building - PRI XIII 100 Sabin Hotel Hotel LLC, 111 Fountain Street | $16.2M | $570,000 | $381,000 | $189,000 | Yes |
| Fountainview Owner LLC, 75 Fountain Street | $15.4M | $541,000 | $441,000 | $100,000 | No |
| High Rock Westminister St LLC, Superman Bldg | $14.1M | $495,000 | $499,000 | $-4,228 | No |
| Providence Capital III LLC, 170 Westminster Street | $12.8M | $450,000 | $288,000 | $162,000 | This is not a requirement for this property owner |
| HSRE_Hampshire Providence, 145 Corliss Street | $11.1M | $389,000 | $148,000 | $241,000 | Yes |
| PCHC Beaman and Smith Mill LLC, 335R Prairie Avenue | $11.0M | $385,000 | $150,000 | $235,000 | No |
| 220 Blackstone Street, LLC, 220 Blackstone Street | $10.5M | $369,000 | $86,000 | $283,000 | Yes |
| Exchange St Hotel LLC (Steeple Street LLC c/o First Bristol Corp), 5 Exchange Street | $10.3M | $363,000 | $155,000 | $208,000 | Yes |
| Hecht Development, 95 Chestnut Street | $8.0M | $279,000 | $21,000 | $258,000 | This is not a requirement for this property owner |
| 345 Harris Inc., 345 Harris Avenue | $7.6M | $268,000 | $95,000 | $173,000 | Yes |
| Providence Capital Holdings LLC, 185 Westminster Street | $7.3M | $255,000 | $230,000 | $25,000 | No |
| 1290 Westminster Street LLC, 1292 Westminster Street | $7.2M | $252,000 | $137,000 | $115,000 | Yes |
| Cromwell Ventures LLC, 55 Cromwell Street | $6.9M | $244,000 | $60,000 | $184,000 | This is not a requirement for this property owner |
| Pearl Street, LLC, 304 Pearl Street | $6.5M | $230,000 | $209,000 | $21,000 | Yes |
| McInnis USA Inc, 39 New York Avenue (Real) | $6.5M | $227,000 | $150,000 | $77,000 | No |
| 30 Kennedy Partners LLC, 59 Westminster Street | $4.5M | $159,000 | $126,000 | $33,000 | No |
| FILI Investment, LLC, 225 Waterman Street | $4.5M | $158,000 | $102,000 | $57,000 | Yes |
| Unison West Fountain, 468 West Fountain Street | $4.4M | $153,000 | $95,000 | $58,000 | Yes |
| Sprague Street Owner, LLC, 50 Sprague Street | $4.3M | $151,000 | $84,000 | $66,000 | Yes |
| HM Ventures Group LLC (HM Ventures Group 8 LLC), 32 Custom House Street | $4.2M | $147,000 | $130,000 | $18,000 | Yes |
| 49 Westfield, 49 Westfield LLC | $4.2M | $146,000 | $54,000 | $92,000 | No |
| Westminster Partners LLC, 203 Westminster Street | $3.9M | $139,000 | $140,000 | $-1,183 | Yes |
| RCG Armory Parkview, LLC, 35 Parade Street | $3.9M | $138,000 | $41,000 | $97,000 | Yes |
| 530 Broadway, LLC, 530 Broadway | $3.9M | $137,000 | $106,000 | $31,000 | Yes |
| HM Ventures Group 8 LLC, 225 Weybosset Street | $3.2M | $113,000 | $77,000 | $36,000 | No |
| Dean Hotel, 122 Fountain Street | $3.2M | $111,000 | $9,601 | $102,000 | This is not a requirement for this property owner |
| 180 GMC LLC, 180 GMC BLVD | $3.1M | $107,000 | $107,000 | $0 | No |
| Federal Hill Partners, LLC ("FHP"), 14 Piedmont Street | $2.9M | $102,000 | $67,000 | $35,000 | Yes |
| 8th Investment LLC, 18 Eighth Street | $2.9M | $100,000 | $73,000 | $27,000 | Yes |
| 271 Tockwotten Partners, LLC, 271 Tockwotten Street | $2.7M | $95,000 | $77,000 | $18,000 | Yes |
| 8 Hewitt Street LLC, 8 Hewitt Street | $2.7M | $95,000 | $27,000 | $67,000 | Yes |
| Sampalis Realty LLC, 203 Weybosset Street | $2.3M | $82,000 | $61,000 | $21,000 | Yes |
| Matilda Pines, LLC, Matilda Pines | $2.1M | $72,000 | $10,000 | $62,000 | Yes |
| Tavares, LLC, 1017 Broad Street | $1.7M | $60,000 | $50,000 | $9,808 | Yes |
| Weybosset LLC, 259 Weybosset Street | $1.6M | $54,000 | $41,000 | $14,000 | No |
| Batwitwash LLC, 473 Washington Street | $1.4M | $51,000 | $25,000 | $26,000 | No |
| Presidio 156, LLC, 156 Westminster Street | $1.3M | $45,000 | $48,000 | $-3,595 | Yes |
| Seventy One Richmond, LLC, Seventy One Richmond | $1.2M | $43,000 | $41,000 | $1,966 | Yes |
| Music House LLC, 103 Dike Street | $1.1M | $37,000 | $12,000 | $25,000 | This is not a requirement for this property owner |
| Wide Plank, LLC, 193 Vinton Street | $650,000 | $23,000 | $15,000 | $8,045 | Yes |
| Art recreation Center (RCG Armory Firehouse LLC), 41 Central Street | $615,000 | $22,000 | $12,000 | $9,326 | No |
| E2000, E2000 | $578,000 | $20,000 | $20,000 | $-173 | No |
| 101 Richmond, LLC, 101 Richmond | $563,000 | $20,000 | $20,000 | $-170 | No |
| FTC Realty, LLC, 292 Academy Avenue | $558,000 | $20,000 | $18,000 | $1,883 | Yes |
| 46 Dike Street Holdings, LLC ("DSH"), 46 Dike Street | $475,000 | $17,000 | $16,000 | $1,031 | Yes |
| Touchdown Realty Group, LLC, 126 Adelaide Avenue assessment cell blank in the report; implied by the bill at $35.10 | $444,000 | $16,000 | $16,000 | $0 | Yes |
| Power 250 LLC, 165 Gano Strreet | $250,000 | $8,793 | $8,793 | $0 | Yes |
| 321 Knight Street. LLC, 321 Knight Street | $193,000 | $6,788 | $11,000 | $-4,377 | Yes |
| 66 agreements with exhibit pages | $980.0M | $34.4M | $15.9M | $18.5M | |
| Printed Table 1 totals, 66 agreements | $1.01B | $35.5M | $15.9M | $19.6M |
City of Providence Internal Auditor, Tax Stabilization Agreements report, FY2025 (August 2025): Table 1 and the exhibit page for each agreement, tax year 2024. “Annual report filed” is the report’s own compliance answer. Prospect CharterCare’s page prints no full-rate column, so its full-rate tax is computed at $35.10 on its printed assessment; 126 Adelaide Avenue’s assessment cell is blank and is implied from its bill. The 2025 roll, after revaluation, carries 137 parcels under these agreements billed $14.9 million against $33.9 million at the new $29.20 rate (Off the Roll).
How the two cities ask
Boston’s 2010 PILOT Task Force set the terms its recap still reports against: every educational, medical and cultural nonprofit holding more than $15 million in property is asked for a quarter of what the property would owe if taxed, the share of the City budget the Task Force tied to police, fire, snow removal and other basic services; generally up to half of the ask can be met with community programs the City credits; the City sets the value basis and publishes the ask, the cash, the credit and the share met every year. Providence has no formula. Each payment is set by its own agreement: the 2023 twenty-year agreement with Brown, RISD, Providence College and Johnson & Wales fixes every year’s payment through fiscal 2043; Brown’s separate ten-year agreement adds $46 million; the hospitals and the mall have agreements of their own. Stabilization agreements are ordinances, one per project, each with its own schedule. The State reimburses Providence for part of the college and hospital tax it does not collect; Massachusetts does not.
What doesn’t line up
- The formula columns are arithmetic, not a record: a quarter of exempt value times each city’s commercial rate. Boston itself does not compute its ask on the roll. It computes it on a value basis of its own, fiscal 2011 values by the City’s account, that runs at about half of roll value, so Boston’s published ask is lower than its own formula on its own roll.
- Years. Providence’s roll is tax year 2025, after revaluation, at $29.20; its payments are fiscal 2025; the stabilization report is tax year 2024 at $35.10. Boston’s roll is fiscal 2026 at $26.96; its recap is fiscal 2025.
- Boston’s roll lists some institutional property under names its adapter does not yet resolve, so a Boston row’s exempt value can run low; rows under half the City’s own basis are flagged. Providence’s six match the live Off the Roll page figure for figure.
- Both cities’ agreements include things this table cannot price: Brown’s credits for development that returns property to the roll, Boston’s community-benefit credits, and the State of Rhode Island’s PILOT payment to Providence.
Not yet on the record
- The CC-15 “39 New York Avenue (Tangible)” agreement: confirmation from the Internal Auditor of its assessment, bill and full-rate tax.
- Which parcels make up each institution’s value basis. On Nov. 6, 2026 the City pointed to its online PILOT property list, filterable by institution; it is not yet matched to the roll here.
- Brown University Health’s payment for 2026 (none is scheduled), Care New England’s renewal, and whether CharterCare’s hospitals, now nonprofit, have a payment agreement.
Data
terms_pvd_bos.csv · terms_pvd_no_agreement.csv · terms_tsa_fy2025.csv
Sources: City of Providence 2025 Property Tax Roll (data.providenceri.gov) and payment agreements; City of Providence Internal Auditor, Tax Stabilization Agreements report, FY2025; City of Boston FY2026 Property Assessment file and FY25 PILOT Recap; City of Boston PILOT Task Force final report, 2010. Built from Off the Roll v0.3 (Providence) and v0.2 (Boston). Data licensed CC BY 4.0: credit “Providence, on the record.”